| 2023 MAFA Rookie Draft 8/12/2023 | |||||
| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | ||
| #1 | Toronto | Ari-CB Ahmad Gardner | WR Christian Watson | CB Kader Kohou | G-T Zach Tom |
| #2 | Maryland | SF-DE Aidan Hutchinson | Ely-T Charles Cross | Ste-CB Kyler Gordon | Tow-C Cole Strange |
| #3 | Santa Fe | Pal-QB Brock Purdy | OLB Travon Walker | Mar-QB Desmond Ridder | Bro-CB Jaylen Watson |
| #4 | Bleeding | Tor-QB Kenny Pickett | WR Treylon Burks | CB Kaiir Elam | C-G Cam Jurgens |
| #5 | Arizona | Mar-WR Garrett Wilson | SF-T Evan Neal | CB Marcus Jones | NC-TE Isaiah Likely |
| #6 | Rock Hill | Mar-WR Chris Olave | Min-RB James Cook | WR Romeo Doubs | Den-WR Isaiah Hodgins |
| #7 | Palmyra | Roc-WR Drake London | S Bryan Cook | Car-OLB James Houston | Den-K-P Ryan Stonehouse |
| #8 | Eugene | DE-LB Kayvon Thiodeaux | Buf-DT Jordan Davis | Ely-G-T Jamaree Salyer | Buf-TE Chigoziem Okonkwo |
| #9 | Springboro | Min-C Tyler Linderbaum | Pit-LB Nakobe Dean | Car-OLB Malcolm Rodriguez | Ble-TE Trey McBride |
| #10 | Steel City | WR George Pickens | Tol-S Jaquan Brisker | Tor-RB Tyer Allgeier | Bro-OLB Boye Mafe |
| #11 | Virginia | RB Breece Hall | NC-WR Alec Pierce | SF-DE Jermaine Johnson | Ble-CB Damarri Mathis |
| #12 | St. Louis | CB Derek Stingley | RB Rachaad White | DT Travis Jones | S Daxton Hill |
| #13 | Kentucky | STL-WR Jameson Williams | Tor-T Bernhard Raimann | STL-CB Andrew Booth | Tow-ILB Troy Andersen |
| #14 | New York | Mar-RB Travis Etienne | STL-ILB Quay Walker | Ble-OLB Arnold Ebiketie | WR Britain Covey |
| #15 | Las Vegas | DE George Karlaftis | WR Richie James | DE Dominique Robinson | Roc-DE Sam Williams |
| #16 | Ridgeville | Den-CB Tariq Woolen | Vir-T Abraham Lucas | Den-CB Alontae Taylor | Eug-ILB Brian Asamoah |
| #17 | Carolina | Ble-T Ikem Ekwonu | Ble-LB Devin Lloyd | WR Rashid Shaheed | Ble-CB Derion Kendrick |
| #18 | Pittsburgh | T Tyler Smith | S Kerby Joseph | Rid-OLB Christian Harris | LB Jahlani Tavai |
| #19 | Conroe | T Braxton Jones | CB Daron Bland | S Damar Hamlin | Tol-QB Bailey Zappe |
| #20 | Brookeville | Mar-RB Kenneth Walker | Tow-QB Sam Howell | Tor-CB Cam Taylor-Britt | Eug-RB Jaylen Warren |
| #21 | Elyria | RB Isaiah Pacheco | CB Martin Emerson | DE Drake Jackson | CB Nick McCloud |
| #22 | New Castle | Ari-G Zion Johnson | S Rodney Thomas | CB Jack Jones | Den-DE Logan Hall |
| #23 | Towson | Tol-S Kyle Hamilton | RB Dameon Pierce | Tol-CB Decobie Durant | Tor-S Reed Blankenship |
| #24 | Buffalo Grove | Car-S Jalen Pitre | T Trevor Penning | Ken-C Luke Fortner | G Kenyon Green |
| #25 | Prescott | Pal-RB Brian Robinson | Bro-CB Roger McCreary | Eug-DE Josh Paschal | Tow-TE Cade Otton |
| #26 | Denver | Rid-CB Trent McDuffie | Ble-DT Devonte Wyatt | Roc-TE Greg Dulcich | Ste-LB EJ Speed |
| #27 | Minneapolis | Roc-C-G Dylan Parham | DE-LB David Ojabo | Roc-TE Josh Oliver | Tor-DE Joseph Ossai |
| #28 | Toledo | WR Jahan Dotson | Tor-WR Skye Moore | Ken-WR Wan’Dale Robinson | Tor-WR Tyquan Thornton |
| Round 5 | Round 6 | Round 7 | Round 8 | ||
| #1 | Toronto | LB Damone Clark | OLB Myjai Sanders | Den-RB Isaiah Spiller | Den-CB Darrell Baker |
| #2 | Maryland | Tow-G Cordell Volson | Tol-CB Akayleb Evans | Den-RB Jerome Ford | Den-QB David Blough |
| #3 | Santa Fe | STL-Khalil Shakir | Bro-S Tony Adams | LV-S Jonathan Owens | LV-S Delarrin Turner-Yell |
| #4 | Bleeding | Buf-DE-OLB Cameron Thomas | Car-S Jeremy Reaves | Tow-CB Zyon McCollum | Den-WR Jalen Nailor |
| #5 | Arizona | G Spencer Burford | RB Jordan Mason | Tow-RB Christian Benford | DL Otito Ogbonnia |
| #6 | Rock Hill | LV-DT Isaiah Buggs | ILB Chad Muma | S Josh Metellus | P Ryan Wright |
| #7 | Palmyra | STL-TE Jelani Woods | NC-WR KaVontae Turpin | G Joshua Ezeudu | DE Alex Wright |
| #8 | Eugene | Bro-OLB Luke Masterson | Buf-QB Malik Willis | Bro-RB Deon Jackson | Mar-S JT Woods |
| #9 | Springboro | NC-DL John Cominsky | Car-RB Malik Davis | Bro-OLB Luiji Vilain | G-T Darian Kinnard |
| #10 | Steel City | Bro-LB Blake Cashman | Vir-HB Parker Hesse | Ken-WR David Bell | STL-G Robert Jones |
| #11 | Virginia | T Nicholas Petit-Frere | Bro-RB Ty Chandler | Ste-WR Velus Jones | Tow-S Geno Stone |
| #12 | St. Louis | Den-S Lewis Cine | Ken-CB Cor’Dale Flott | HB Ko Kieft | LV-G Jack Anderson |
| #13 | Kentucky | CB Coby Bryant | Tow-LB Terrel Bernard | Bro-OLB Kinsgley Enagbare | NY-CB Christian Holmes |
| #14 | New York | Buf-G Luke Goedeke | NC-CB Joshua Williams | RB Justice Hill | Tow-RB Zonovan Knight |
| #15 | Las Vegas | STL-G Ed Ingram | Tow-ILB Christian Rozeboom | C-G Nick Leverett | WR Phillip Dorsett |
| #16 | Ridgeville | Ely-WR Trent Sherfield | RB Kyren Williams | DL DeMarvin Leal | Ken-RB Caleb Huntley |
| #17 | Carolina | TE Jake Ferguson | CB Ja’Sir Taylor | DL Matt Henningsen | T Daniel Faalele |
| #18 | Pittsburgh | CB Keisean Nixon | TE Daniel Bellinger | Ari-RB Khari Blasingame | Tol-S Quintin Lake |
| #19 | Conroe | Tow-DL Marquise Copeland | CB Keion Crossen | OLB Darius Harris | P-JK Scott |
| #20 | Brookeville | Rid-CB Brandon Stephens | Rid-CB Dallis Flowers | LV-ILB Dylan Cole | Eug-WR Steven Sims |
| #21 | Elyria | ILB Micah McFadden | S Dane Belton | WR Trent Taylor | Eug-P Corliss Waitman |
| #22 | New Castle | Tow-ILB Jack Sanborn | Tol-RB Zamir White | C-G Hjalte Froholdt | Tol-K Cameron Dicker |
| #23 | Towson | DT Phildarian Mathis | RB Keaontay Ingram | NC-P Jake Camarda | NY-HB Giovanni Ricci |
| #24 | Buffalo Grove | DL Zachary Carter | ILB Channing Tindall | Tow-T Max Mitchell | Car-K Cade York |
| #25 | Prescott | Pal-RB Hassan Haskins | Ste-G-T Alaric Jackson | Ari-S Russ Yeast | Tol-TE Charlie Kolar |
| #26 | Denver | Tor-LB Leo Chenal | Bro-WR Kyle Phillips | Buf-S Nick Cross | Bro-ILB Jack Gibbens |
| #27 | Minneapolis | DE Michael Clemons | OLB Nik Bonitto | LV-WR Trenton Irwin | Car-P Jamie Gillan |
| #28 | Toledo | Roc-RB Pierre Strong | Jalyn Armour-Davis | NY-G-T Chandler Brewer | NC-DE-LB Tomon Fox |